The first, and worse, of two mangles from BBC 1’s
Watchdog a couple of weeks ago. This is a detail of a tee-shirt specially made for a ‘rogue trader’ exposed on the programme:
This mangling of the Gospel of John, 8:7, is hideous, but certainly isn’t unique. For instance, ‘Let he who is without sin’ is the title of
Star Trek: Deep Space Nine, series 5, episode 7. However, the
Star Trek franchise has never set itself up as an authority on English grammar, unlike the BBC, which offers English courses for
children and
adults, but doesn’t seem to require its staff to lead by example or, where necessary, take a remedial course.
The phrase suffers from hypercorrection, defined by
Oxford Dictionaries as ‘[t]he use of an erroneous word form or pronunciation based on a false analogy with a correct or prestigious form, such as the use of
I instead of
me as a grammatical object (as in
he invited my husband and I to lunch)’.
Let he who is without sin